Letter to an Oregon Facility (anonymized)
Below is a letter I wrote to an Oregon medical facility that has gone mask-optional. You are more than welcome to paraphrase my words to create your own pro-masking message if you’re struggling to come up with one. Sources all listed at the end!
As a direct result of [organization]’s decision as an organization to lift live-saving mask mandates, disabled and immunocompromised communities are no longer able to safely access [organization]’s services, work/volunteer inside [organization] locations, or even recommend [organization] as a safe place to receive care. Covid is still killing over 1,000 people in just the US alone per week,1 and the WHO, despite dropping their Covid emergency status, admitted on 4/26/2023 that “An estimated 1 in 10 infections results in post Covid-19 condition, suggesting that hundreds of millions of people will need longer-term care.”2 We know that Covid can cause increased nerve damage,3 can cause vascular issues that greatly increase risk of DVT, heart attack, and stroke.4 We know that Covid can cause brain damage and cognitive issues.5 Covid also continues to become more and more contagious. We saw how much more contagious Omicron is, and while some people may be experiencing less severe acute illness, we are seeing that these new strains are highly transmissible and are just as likely to cause post-viral conditions.
In an article6 from August 2020, CNN writer Harmeet Kaur recorded a statement from Dr. Thomas Steinemann, a clinical spokesperson for the American Academy of Opthalmology.
“Steinemann said that if a significant number of people were getting infected through their eyes, doctors would probably see more Covid-19 patients with conjunctivitis, also known as pink eye.” At the time of this article, Steinemann was discussing the lack of need for eye protection. However, he makes a point that he couldn’t have known would be so relevant to today: Covid strain XBB.1.16 AKA “Arcturus,” is causing many Covid patients to develop conjunctivitis. In fact, that is the new symptom to look out for characterizing this strain of the virus.
Do you know what would help less virus particles enter the air? If everyone was wearing a mask. Masks work when used properly.7 One-way masking is significantly more risky, especially with these new variants8. I know that your company is following a trend right now, but it is a populist trend that is not based in science, and you directly contradict your inclusivity and ethics statement by revoking mask mandates for all who enter your facility.
“[organization] works to create a safe and comfortable environment for all members of our community. We welcome people of all genders, sexes, races, colors, incomes, national origins, ages, abilities or disabilities, marital statuses (legal or otherwise), familial situations, religions, sizes and shapes, sexual orientations, and political beliefs. Your level of care will never be based on any of these factors.”9 Let’s break this down in the current context. If disabled and immunocompromised people are at a higher risk for Covid, and if two-way masking is an effective strategy against the spread of Covid, and your facility does not require masks – this means that your disabled and immunocompromised patients, volunteers, and employees are less safe at your facility. This means that the care they receive is lesser than the care received by your able-bodied patients. That is frankly absurd and you should be ashamed of yourselves as an organization if you continue to not require masks for everyone who enters your facility. With the removal of mask mandates in medical settings, disabled and immunocompromised people are struggling to find safe, equitable medical care. You have an opportunity to set a good example. When things go bad, don’t go with them. You have the chance to show the greater [city] community that you care about the safety and wellbeing of your patients.
You are at a crossroads right now. On one path is eugenics; dismissing the real medical concerns of disabled people as “anxieties” the way that Dean Sidelinger of the OHA does, dismissing the existence of Long Covid and the risk of more people developing it in the future. You can put your blinders on and wonder why you and your staff continue to get sick over and over again as your brains become foggier and foggier. Or you can take a stand for the disabled community that you claim to equitably serve and maintain a universal masking mandate for your company. I understand that you even checked in with your employees. However, I urge you to check out the sources that I have linked to this letter. There is information that supports avoiding Covid that many Americans just don’t know about. Genuinely, the decision to allow partial masking, optional masking, any form of non-universal masking, is a decision made in ignorance, against your best interests and the best interests of everyone in your communities.
What can we do from here? If you’re so committed to having mask-optional facilities to accommodate anti-maskers, then you need to have some level of precautions in place for your disabled, immunocompromised, chronically ill patients. We previously briefly discussed the following options:
1. One or more location could maintain the universal masking while another location allows optional masking.
2. Certain days could be mask-only, or even certain time frames (I know many covid-conscious people prefer to schedule their appointments as early in the day as possible, so there is less risk of contamination posed (versus coming to an appointment in the afternoon or evening, where unmasked people have been exhaling virus all day).
3. Are masked home visits something that the [organization] is capable of facilitating?
If you just go mask-optional and don’t have something like this to offer to disabled and immunocompromised people, you’re going against your ethics statement and participating in the eugenics movement that is growing in this country. 9
Learning to live with Covid means implementing precautions. It should not mean throwing caution to the wind and allowing Covid to damage whoever, however. Covid is not going away anytime soon and as such we need to wear masks. Genuinely, this logic of “covid is here to stay, let her rip,”: what is the long term plan with that? Can you think for yourself as an organization, or do you need Dean Sidelinger to do it for you? Knowing all that we know about Covid and Long Covid, we have every reason to continue to try to prevent transmission. What are the reasons for unmasking? Superficial smiles? Is seeing someone’s smile, and showing your smile to others, worth having a heart attack over? Is it worth the increased nerve pain, the brain fog, the DVT? Do you really want to play Russian Roulette with Covid every day? Let me repeat what the WHO said recently: 1 in 10 infections will result in Long Covid. Not 1 in 10 people, but 1 in 10 infections. Do you want to keep rolling that 10-sided dice, just expecting that you will never roll a 1? Please be on the side of science and reason. Please stick true to your ethics and inclusion statement. Please do not drop your company mask mandates.
Sincerely,
Gabriel L
sources:
1 https://covid.cdc.gov/covid-data-tracker/#trends_weeklydeaths_select_00
2 https://twitter.com/i/broadcasts/1YqxoArNjANGv
3 https://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/pmc/articles/PMC9214475/ 4 https://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/pmc/articles/PMC7556303/
5 https://www.nature.com/articles/s41586-022-04569-5
6 https://amp.cnn.com/cnn/2020/07/31/health/covid-19-through-eyes-wellness- trnd/index.html?fbclid=IwAR3pM3AV0G8dChypToyLln_pyLcG9l7XyNnvMvj- 69AMOfn5CGs7lMt24yw&mibextid=Zxz2cZ
7 https://www.cdc.gov/mmwr/volumes/71/wr/mm7106e1.htm
8 https://slate.com/technology/2022/02/one-way-masking-coronavirus-protection-vulnerable.html
9 https://blog.petrieflom.law.harvard.edu/2021/07/23/covid-eugenics-health-based-discrimination/
Comments
Post a Comment